close
close

Guiltandivy

Source for News

What Braylon Mullins Choosing UConn Means for IU Basketball Mike Woodson
Update Information

What Braylon Mullins Choosing UConn Means for IU Basketball Mike Woodson

BLOOMINGTON — Braylon Mullins committed to UConn on Wednesday, his decision becoming the latest pivot for an IU fan base that is undeniably divided on the status quo surrounding the men's basketball program.

Maybe it shouldn't.

Make no mistake: Losing Mullins to the Huskies — like losing Jalen Haralson to Notre Dame — is a blow to Mike Woodson and his staff. They put a lot of time and effort into recruiting both players, each of them among the first in-state prospects Woodson clearly targeted as a priority, and now two talented players from Indiana's recruiting back yard will be playing college basketball elsewhere Bloomington.

Perhaps no one will better understand the importance of local flavor on an IU squad than Woodson, an Indianapolis native who enrolled at Broad Ripple to become one of the Hoosiers' all-time greats. Mullins would have helped Indiana immediately. Now he will immediately help someone else. This is not a positive development.

But in his four years in office, Woodson has never made locking down his home state a top priority. He has moved on to state commitments, most recently Trent Sisley, formerly of Heritage Hills and now at Montverde Academy in Florida. But Woodson's recruiting ethos at the prep level seems to boil down to this: Indiana will compete for either a) players he believes are suited to the way it wants to develop long-term, b) elite high school talent, or c) both.

When it can't fill its roster with players who meet those criteria, it turns to the portal, which is sometimes held up as an example of Woodson's inability to effectively plan for the future.

Here we encounter a question more fundamental than whether Indiana will succeed or fail without Braylon Mullins: Is the transfer portal as effective a tool for roster construction and management as high school recruiting?

The answer is yes.

In college basketball, the word “transfer” has long been associated with a label. Transfers were extreme cases, both a player's mistake in going somewhere he didn't stay and a program's mistake in allowing a hole to appear on its roster that it couldn't fill in the normal way with prep recruits.

That was never entirely fair, of course, but transfers – and particularly successful transfers – were so rare that they could be treated as outliers.

This changed about 10 to 12 years ago when players toward the end of their careers began taking advantage of the graduate transfer exemption to up-transfer (the practice of moving from a smaller program to a larger one). We in the media treated this like an epidemic (it wasn't), a problem in need of a solution (it wasn't). And for people who didn't like it, those were quickly the good old days.

This has all been bundled into the larger push for athlete rights in college sports, the repetition of which is not important to this discussion. It is important to understand that the evolution of the practice in the six years since the portal's launch represents a systemic shock that we are still grappling with after spending literally decades severely restricting the practice of athlete transfer.

To a certain extent, the portal is still considered a last resort. The glass that breaks in an emergency if plans A, B, C and D don't work out. Woodson didn't treat it that way.

Make no mistake, Indiana would be better off next year with Braylon Mullins or Jalen Haralson. But preventing their absence through the transfer portal isn't a lack of planning. It's a choice.

Since being hired, Woodson has invested much of his time and capital into recruiting aimed at either elite high school talent or high-profile portal recruits. Of course, that didn't always work, but it was clearly the plan. Indiana has added players like Gabe Cupps, Jakai Newton, Sisley and others who it believes are potentially good prospects and who could develop over multiple years of college. But beyond that, the company has consistently prioritized either high-end apprenticeship candidates or the portal, with the underlying assumption that Indiana wants ready-to-work talent.

The counterargument is consistently that this is a dangerous strategy. That Woodson had better put his portal recruiting into action or else. But when isn't that the case? Every rostering strategy carries risks. There is no end game to all of this, which essentially boils down to “This is so good the games don't actually matter” and the idea of ​​building a squad on robust NIL support used to recruit high-profile transfers, is just as valid a way to fill your locker room as any modern college basketball.

It comes with the warning that portal recruits tend to have a shorter shelf life in college, and that's true in the most fundamental sense. Just this spring and summer, Indiana added four players from the portal – Oumar Ballo, Luke Goode, Langdon Hatton and Dallas James – whose eligibility will be exhausted after next season.

But in the modern climate, should coaches seriously consider an out-of-season player? You are constantly re-recruiting your squad and there is no absolute guarantee that they will not consider the portal.

Wednesday's loss to Mullins is a blow to Woodson's plan for next season's squad. Just like the loss of Boogie Fland a year ago or Liam McNeeley last spring. And in their place, the Hoosiers added a McDonald's All American and, yes, from the portal, the Pac-12 Freshman of the Year. There's every chance someone equally promising will fill the void now left by Mullin's commitment to UConn.

It's still up to Woodson and his staff to implement the plan, whatever it may be. This time, it's likely they'll be preparing for another trip through the transfer portal again next spring. It won't be a desperate play, just an embrace of modern college basketball roster construction.

Listen to Mind Your Banners, our IU athletics podcast, on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *